I think out of the two, I definitely prefer Isabelle! They're both really good OCs, with a lot of thought put into them but Isabelle gets my vote since I just really love her aesthetic more. She seems like a really colourful and lovable protagonist! She's got a lot of attitude too! [I also lowkey appreciate the Cardcaptor Sakura gif]
This thread has rules regarding the effort you have to put in your replies. Please read them carefully before claiming and posting. Violation of these rules could lead to a warning or a ban from my forum games.
This game is simple to play! Post the link to two of your OCs (don't make people have to search through all of your characters lmao), and the user below has to tell which one they prefer and why! (With an OOC explanation) Then they post two of their OCs as well, and so on.
The two OCs to choose from can be anything! They may be related in some way in their story, they may be similar, they may be polar opposites, they may have the same number of faves, they may be chosen at random... Go wild and have fun comparing OCs ~
Rules and guidelines
About your claims
- Read the above OCs' bios, and do comment about them, not just the designs. Bringing up the designs is fine, but it must not be the only thing you talk about. Preferences based on appearances only are better suited for the low-effort version of this game.
- Write an actual, thoughtful reason of why you prefer a character over another. A simple "I like their design better" or "I find them more interesting" and nothing else isn't really enough; try to be specific.
- Be fair: if the person above you took the time to write a paragraph, don't give them one or two short sentences only in return.
- Stay nice when you explain why you prefer one character over another. Don't make passive-aggressive, inappropriate remarks on other people characters, whether it's the duo or just the one you didn't choose. It's a 'who you prefer' choice, not a 'who you dislike the less' one.
About the characters you post
- Please make sure the OCs you post have bios with enough substance for the next poster to have something to write about them.
- If you got no response after a long time (let's say 1 or 2 days), it's recommended to edit the end of your post, suggesting a new duo to make the thread keep going.
- For everyone's comfort, please refrain from posting NSFW or otherwise possibly disturbing characters. If you really do want to use such OCs, please offer a second pair to choose from, so the game doesn't get stuck.
If you find these rules too strict and want to play a low effort comparison game instead, you can try this variant!
Let's start for real now! Who do you prefer between Isabelle and Ismaël?
I prefer Naria~
Kimiko is super cute design wise, but Naria's personality appeals to me a lot more along with her backstory. I like 'hard to get' characters especially ones who, once they trust you, will be super super devoted to you and Naria seems like that type of chara.
--
who do you prefer between-
https://toyhou.se/1195312.haruka ( Haruka )
https://toyhou.se/1658389.reika (Reika)
I prefer Reika! I find her concept very original, and I love her theme song (I knew it before the creation of Reika but it's always cool to hear it again lmao) ~ I also think that her design is more thought-out and detailed, but this doesn't mean I don't like Haruka's one of course!
Arienne! I love her design, and I really like characters who are associated with the moon in general. Plus, her liking rabbits kind of made me chuckle a little, it's so cute and fitting! She also has heaps of nice art ; v ;
Who do you prefer between my two edgy more troubled characters, Ashley or Liam?
i gotta say that i prefer liam, mostly because i guess in a way i relate to him with the shutting down when feeling nervous and just not talking thing and not being comfortable with tough (tho for me it's for different reasons but still), and i'm also dense and get lost in thought way too easily haha
he just feels like a realistic character to me despite having a small profile and i'd love to read more about him honestly! i also love how he has a little rabbit, it's a cute addition that - even small - still adds to his personality, i think
anyway yeah! i mostly like him more because i sorta relate to him but also because he feels like a realistic character!
---
for me, have two opposite characters from fantasy (ashari) to sci-fi (kymer)
I'd have to say Kymer! As much as I like dragons and like Ashari's story, Kymer's species and Kymer in general are also very very interesting :0 I had to skim because I wasnt feeling too well but from the stuff I read, Kymer is super interesting.
Well, a classic on my page right now: Who do you prefer, Denver or Piko?
I'd say Denver! I'm weak for vampires personally and his aesthetic resonates with me + I somehow find it really endearing in his character how he tries to fake his accent ; v ; Also his design is cute, I love the black-blue hair a lot & it looks super soft and poofy!
My two most popular characters on TH apparently, which one do you prefer: Claude or Ambrosius?
I like Whisky more! I have a soft spot for older characters, and how he looks "edgy" but is actually a cutie. it's also super funny to know he had an emo phase, i imagine him cringing to nowadays like "iT WAS A PHASE" xiubvodibsdkgsd
My two favorites(at the moment) on toyhouse: Would you prefer Collin or Leslie ?
Octiva~ Her colours are so pleasing and her fish-monster look is adorable~ I love her bubbly sweet personality so much and honestly it's just her design is so good *_*
--
https://toyhou.se/1195312.haruka (Haruka)
OR
https://toyhou.se/1195237.jung (Jung!)
Definitely Haruka. For one thing, she's much more recognisable, but her story is also more interesting. They both have really fleshed out personalities, but Haruka is a lot...nicer than Jung is, if a bit distant.
Let's see who wins the popularity contest between Bozard and James, my two beloved dragons.