timeandtimor Claim!
edit: I'm sorry, something came up and I have to finish this in the morning. I won't forget!
I'm so sorry that took so long! I was unexpectedly busy after claiming you, and I didn't want to rush looking through your writing. I really enjoyed reading your pieces-- I think my favorites were "Falling," "Cigarette Daydreams," "Come Hell or High Water," "Peonies," "Character Study," and "Knocked Senseless," especially the last three. It's hard to pick a single favorite-- they're each compelling for different reasons.
"Character Study" is such a short, sweet little thing and I really admire the economy. It's just a tiny moment and it doesn't need to be anything more, but this simple encounter tells me so much about Adrian as a character and how important his sister was to him, and I love that-- there's elegance in that. It's sweet how this little girl's innocent observation brought all those memories back to him, and how he instantly saw the girl in a protective, big-brotherly way: it's a selfless sort of reminiscence. He doesn't know the girl at all, but he immediately is concerned for her like she were his sister, and that says a lot about what kind of person he is and how much he loved his sister.
"Peonies" I loved for the conceit-- the whole thing is framed around the forgotten vase in Shizue's room and how he feels like it parallels himself, useless and unloved, and I like that; it's a unique and compelling device. You write his mental state very well, all his thoughts as he stares at the vase, unable to avoid seeing it but also unable to make himself do something about it. I felt for him, and I was rooting for him both to get some flowers and to get some TLC himself. His surprise and disbelief in Wisteria's visit and concern is sad-- but it was sweet to see that Shizue was wrong and that someone does care for him. The piece has a nice flow that allows the reader to follow along with Shizue's isolation up to the realization that he isn't isolated after all, and I just enjoyed it.
"Knocked Senseless" is the longest of the pieces I liked best, though, so I suppose if I'm picking one favorite, I'll go with that one. It's such a classic teenage/young adult adventure, daring someone to go in the local haunted house, but it's written with a lot of unique flavor, suspense, and character study that make it compelling. Even with the mutant setting, everything felt very relatable and real: I didn't believe Dahlia really meant to hurt Marcus, and even if I don't share all the fears Marcus has, his mental state was written so well that anyone could feel his dread and terror right alongside him. There were little bits of humor mixed into the horror setting, and I really like that-- it's realistic; everyone's mind wanders even when they're afraid. I loved these little things, like Marcus being concerned "someone could have died in there" while it's the apocalypse seems very funny, or his concern about the cobwebs messing up his nice hair, or his fixation on the idea of mutated mice and whether or not he could take them on. You wrote a really good progression from his initial apprehension but agreeableness to do this dare, to his claustrophobic fear of being shut in the house, to rallying his bravery to actually explore the house and prove himself to Dahlia (I loved his "I am not scared" mantra-- I was proud of him for actually checking out all those creepy rooms upstairs! I don't know if I would have gone in the room with scratches at the door and noises coming from inside, but I have to give him kudos for the courage to do that), to the real fear he experiences when he finds out that there really is a monster in this house, and how that panic, realistically, makes him hurt himself and makes the situation worse. You wrote the monster so well, too-- it came across as horrible and revolting, not an evil beast but something mindless and unyielding, and that's often even scarier. Bless Dahlia for saving him in the end-- that last paragraph stayed with me the most, her regret for doing something that she thought would have been good for her friend, but hurt him in more than just a physical way. That's why I liked this piece perhaps the best: you used this common story setup to tell a story that's not really about a haunted house at all.