Beware: Tabanei (1-7-2019 UPDATE)

Posted 8 months, 6 days ago (Edited 1 month, 3 days ago) by umbral-wind

Updates will be posted at the bottom of the thread.

Hello! I never thought I'd have to write a bad review about another artist, but I've finally run into a situation that pushed me past my limit.

Who: Tabanei @ TH / dA
What: 2 waist up experimentally colored images.
When: June 25th of 2017
Issue: Art remains undelivered as of June 9th 2018 despite being paid for, contact has been dropped multiple times.

I'll try and keep this concise as possible because I just want to get straight to the point. My notes have been ignored by Tabanei at various intervals of our transaction and the most I've received was some extremely basic skeleton sketches for posing and a piece of apology art.

June 25th - Dec 11th 2017. For the sake of recording these dates side by side, these are the notes that went back and forth for the payment, and then my first prodding in December.
Here is the note where the the invoice had been sent.
Here is the invoice in question, paid by myself.
Here is the Dec 11th response from Tabanei & my providing of new references.

On Jan 28th I checked in again using a note from our previous correspondence and received no immediate response.

On Jan 30th I received an apology as well as art that had nothing to do with what I paid for. While I was thankful to receive something, I can't help but feel bitter that time and effort was wasted giving me something I didn't pay for.

On the 12th of Feb I received some poses as well as a reminder about the gift art. I hadn't responded initially because I was annoyed that anything was done but what I was paid for, but I failed to mention it directly to Tabanei because I hadn't wanted to sour our relationship before our business was complete.
On the same day, I responded thankfully and also provided new references. This note remains unread as of posting this thread.

On April 15th, I sent a note on dA because of my ignored TH note.
I was ignored yet again, so I tweeted them because it was the only place I knew Tabanei was active,
This prompted a relatively quick response which was sent on April 22nd.

As instructed, I provided new references again on the same day along with my honest feelings on the situation, but this note also remains unread as of posting this thread.

Today (June 9th) I gave Tabanei one stern message & a warning that I would be posting this thread.

_____

As a closing message, I just want to clear up some things. On the outside I'm impatient as hell, I love getting new art and I'm always triple checking my inboxes when I sent off information. On the inside however, I can be extremely lenient and patient. The only thing I require is contact, honesty, and the ability to pull out of an agreement at any time if I'm not getting what I paid for. It's what I offer to my own customers, and it's all I would expect from others.

I understand that art takes time and the best pieces are done when someone is enjoying themselves. I am by no means a quick artist, I've taken several months to a year on pieces myself. But I will never intentionally shirk contact with my buyers, nor will I ever trap them into an agreement where they aren't offered a refund as an alternative when I have nothing to give with an update.

Dropping contact is inexcusable. This is a business transaction with real money involved and your customer deserves as much respect as anyone or anything else in the real world that deals with real money transactions. Your buyers are not people you can simply forget or put on the back-burner until it's convenient for you.

Either way, I hope this issue gets resolved and that Tabanei learns from their mistakes.

Thanks for reading.

____________________

Update: June 11th I received a response to my last note, with a promise to finish the owed art.

Update 2: June 19th I received one of my commissions complete, there is still one more to go.

Update 3: After a bit of back and forth with WIPs, both pieces have been completed and delivered to me on July 21st, concluding my business with Tabanei.

Follow up message:

Although this warning has done well to push forth the reality of the situation and see my pieces to completion (and with no shortage of effort, I might add!) I am deeply hoping that Tabanei offers their remaining customers the same amount of effort they offered me. As far as I'm aware, there are still a number of unfinished commissions, so this beware will remain up as a precaution to those who may consider ordering in the future, and for those who are still awaiting their products as well.

I encourage everyone to post here if they get updates on their commissions, so that we might have a point of reference regarding whether or not others are being done.

UPDATE 1-7-2019:

My commission was finished, and I was ready to be done with this thread hoping Tabanei has learned her lesson, but unfortunately that is not the case. At least two users are still being ignored in regards to contact about overdue commissions, some which have been going on for months without any response. I would not commission this user at all, as they've shown that as of right now with their outstanding commissions they cannot be trusted to finish or refund past projects, much less keep in contact with customers in a reasonable timeframe.

Vin MisoHungry both have contacted me/this thread asking if anyone else has come to me speaking of their commissions being finished. If they wish to show images of their correspondence via comments on this thread, I'll link to the individual posts to show them.

-- MisoHungry's proof
-- Hannibaru's proof

vestigance

/Edit/ Thank you Beau for letting me share here!

What: CYOP Collestian

When: July 11 2017 - Current

Issue: CYOP remains unfinished as of 6/9/2018

Next month, it will be this order's one year anniversary. As with Beau, I have been offered compensation art while Tabanei does not understand the primary care is what was paid for.

Original Auction https://sta.sh/02bddf65q9vg

Auction Timestamp https://sta.sh/01i3yv7y963m

Payment Request / Payment Confirmed same day (as auction) https://sta.sh/01nsnamhc7qe

https://sta.sh/0e4nsont3hc

Heads-up from Tabanei of delay https://sta.sh/024nxhwtz5x2

But at first, everything seemed fine as within the first month I received a wip... https://sta.sh/01ge14d8p1r0

https://sta.sh/014jxw6tyi0i

https://sta.sh/01ljqbe4vzxs

https://sta.sh/01rjao1yf6ev

And then she had gone silent for months on end. As DA occassionally had some notes issue, I tried to give her benefit of the doubt. https://sta.sh/02fdve15eipz

https://sta.sh/0n19wgqaz42

Since then she had completely dropped off the radar https://sta.sh/027saa8nawvz

https://sta.sh/01gf2dxdjvnl

** **

Ever since buying this collestian, I had been informed by multiple people Tabanei is difficult to work with, and even for those she had delivered orders, there were long delays. I had disregarded their feedback, because I had unfortunately loved her species, and plus it was only a coloring job...

Since things have reached this undesirable point, I have also been informed by friends Tabanei during the period had been active in discord, giving away art and answering inquiries about new commissions while ignoring notes and followups from existing orders. She also reportedly had deactivated her paypal.

Due to my following of Yukibuns community, I have also personally seen Tabanei repeatedly offer on OTAs back when they had been fully public: https://sta.sh/0245la20p4re More examples unfortunately cannot be provided as most OTA bulletins had been taken down.

So Tabanei was by no means completely inactive in the past few months as she claims to Beau of real life issues.

vvingblade

I'm sure you do, but do you intend to open a dispute with Paypal? I'm aware youre over the time limit, but you have a strong case and calling in usually works even beyond the dispute time limit.

umbral-wind

vvingblade If I'm met with silence yet again and art/a refund isn't delivered within a reasonable time since this post then yes, I do. I definitely don't want to be out of my money if I'm not getting any art.

vestigance

vvingblade - according to January’s guide in the other thread calling in only has a chance of working when having paid from paypal balance (nothing associated with bank or cards).

vestigance

MisoHungry - Yomie, do you know about when Tabanei's paypal was down/inactive? As of 7/11 for my CYOP her paypal was functional. I did email her there too, but of course no response.

sakumintsu

I have a small follow up since I am on the to-do list that everyone is on (Sakura20010):

I've commissioned Tabanei twice, one headshot (which I now use as my avatar) and one halfbody.

The first commission was completed quickly and it came with some extra art that came later: https://sta.sh/02e5isqbof86

The second commission didn't go nearly as smoothly, but it did end up being completed (https://toyhou.se/1042898.yin#5786552). The time frame was between June 8th to Dec 20th, with one apology on Oct 19th. A WIP was sent on Dec 19th and the commission was completed the next day. https://sta.sh/02bjumbq1mlh

I also told Tabanei to put me on the end of her list, since I was a bit late to send the payment: https://sta.sh/0tn79q3m80r so I find it strange that my commission was completed before others when I was the last on the list. I also tend to be overly patient to artists I'm commissioning so when she sent me the apology in October, I told her she can take her time. I also sent no check in messages in between so I'm very surprised that she actually finished my commission considering everybody else's experience with her.

kii

Update (6/16/2018): Got a twitter DM and a WIP to choose pose for one of the commissions! Glad to hear from them!

Update (6/29/2018): Received the first commission! Now waiting on second one!

Update (7/20/2018): Received sketch of poses to choose from for second one!

Update (8/26/2018): Received flat color WIP for second one!

Update (1/7/2019): Sent a DM asking for progress.


I'm on the slot list linked by MisoHungry above (thanks for the screenshot!!).

All relevant screenshots here.

May 26th, 2017 - Ordered and paid for a flat color waist up

June 28th, 2017 - Upgraded previous flat color waist up to hybrid cell shaded waist up, ordered additional hybrid cell shaded waist up, and paid

November 8th, 2017 - Encouraged by a friend to ask for an update

November 9th, 2017 - Was told they had overdue commissions to work on and will do their best to contact me when they have time

June 11, 2018 - Sent a final follow up and offered that they can either finish the art or send me a full refund

Between these above dates, they opened and completed adopts, chibi commissions/art for OTAs, art trades, and various personal art before touching older commissions. I've seen them post bulletins/tweet about the death of their rabbit (around November), their grandpa getting ill (around January), or about their slump in general as excuses to delaying owed arts.

Sans-Ailes

Aah, this is a bit upsetting to see- I'm a fan of their work and Collestian species... after having bought a closed species adopt from them (I own one Collestian, but she's not listed on toyhou.se), I was hoping to commission them at some point. The transaction and delivery of files for the already-completed adopt was handled swiftly, and I hadn't noticed any red flags when doing business with them in this manner... but this is just terrible. ;;

Thank you for the warning; I'll definitely make sure to exercise caution if I ever do business with them again... though I'm going to refrain from commissioning them for sure... ;;

kii

MisoHungry I've been in contact with them through Twitter, though our last correspondence was about 2 weeks ago. Maybe you can try tweeting directly at them since maybe they didn't see your DM? I know that Twitter separates Inbox and Requests into separate [email protected]@ Good luck!