This user's account has been closed.
This thread has rules regarding the effort you have to put in your replies. Please read them carefully before claiming and posting. Violation of these rules could lead to a warning or a ban from my forum games.
This game is simple to play! Post the link to two of your OCs (don't make people have to search through all of your characters lmao), and the user below has to tell which one they prefer and why! (With an OOC explanation) Then they post two of their OCs as well, and so on.
The two OCs to choose from can be anything! They may be related in some way in their story, they may be similar, they may be polar opposites, they may have the same number of faves, they may be chosen at random... Go wild and have fun comparing OCs ~
Rules and guidelines
About your claims
- Read the above OCs' bios, and do comment about them, not just the designs. Bringing up the designs is fine, but it must not be the only thing you talk about. Preferences based on appearances only are better suited for the low-effort version of this game.
- Write an actual, thoughtful reason of why you prefer a character over another. A simple "I like their design better" or "I find them more interesting" and nothing else isn't really enough; try to be specific.
- Be fair: if the person above you took the time to write a paragraph, don't give them one or two short sentences only in return.
- Stay nice when you explain why you prefer one character over another. Don't make passive-aggressive, inappropriate remarks on other people characters, whether it's the duo or just the one you didn't choose. It's a 'who you prefer' choice, not a 'who you dislike the less' one.
About the characters you post
- Please make sure the OCs you post have bios with enough substance for the next poster to have something to write about them.
- If you got no response after a long time (let's say 1 or 2 days), it's recommended to edit the end of your post, suggesting a new duo to make the thread keep going.
- For everyone's comfort, please refrain from posting NSFW or otherwise possibly disturbing characters. If you really do want to use such OCs, please offer a second pair to choose from, so the game doesn't get stuck.
If you find these rules too strict and want to play a low effort comparison game instead, you can try this variant!
Let's start for real now! Who do you prefer between Isabelle and Ismaël?
hmmmmmmmmmmm i gotta go with cheddar on this one!! i really like rat characters and her design n color palette really calls out to me + also the detail of her having like the swiss cheese spots on her cheeks is really cute!
susurro and fin whale! both don't have bio's yet so feel free to go off by just design alone / but for more options have erin n emma ( •̀ ω •́ )✧
v aaaah, thank you so so much!! i'm happy you like them :3
ill just do both!!
between the first two, i'd go with fin whale!! susurro has a super cool design that honestly looks really fun to draw, but I have such a big bias for anything aquatic, and fin whales just so cute!!
between erin and emma, it's honestly a hard choice but I'd go with emma! Normally Erin is the type of character I'd absolutely adore, and honestly I do adore him a bunch! (it was super fun reading through all the info written for them both) but also I have a love for cheery characters that have Just a Little More than what's on the surface, I think she'd be super neat to be friends with, and also interesting to see as a character too^^ also its neat seeing characters that lack amazing magical prowess in any kind of magic based settings!
Koralo and Lunele!! They're both adopted siblings so I thought it'd be fun to put them here ^^ Their profiles aren't completely finished in some parts, but enough is there to give a good grasp of them!
Lunele - I generally prefer calm, protective characters whose true selves are just utter dorks. Koralo's a pretty good character, but his personality doesn't really draw me in like his sister's does. Lunele has more complexity to who she is, while Koralo is more straightforward - which isn't a bad thing, just not what I'm drawn to in a character. I also favour blue palettes over pinks and reds (blue's my favourite colour, lol). Both their designs are nice, it's really the personality that is the differentiating point to me.
Let's see... How about Xarxus and Izar? Those two have the most extensively-written profiles (they also live in the same universe, though hail from different planets).
Rilameth (pinging since it's been 2 weeks)
I'd go for Izar! Design-wise, I tend to lean towards characters with realistic physical traits more, and Izar's outfit is also very elegant! Love the cape especially, it gives him a nice silhouette :] Personality-wise he's also very much my thing, I do have a soft spot for characters who seem cold at first sight but actually just have trouble expressing their emotions ;; <3
Xarxus' personality is very interesting as well, I love how he's both a polite scholar and a dork haha, I just tend to relate to Izar more! Also he rebelled against his parents when they tried to force him into marrying and starting a family? Absolute power more, aspec icon
Isabelle; I just like the design more and kinda prefers female characters over male ones. I also like her story- very detailed and I also love her personality. Everything about her is cool, she has very good skills and the story truly expresses her feelings and emotions.
-----
I enjoy both of these characters, but I'm going to go with Aliah!
Aliah's design in particular really grabbed my attention. I especially love her pallet as well as her outfit. I am also interested in her story, and would like to know more of her motives for setting the fire and what led up to that! I feel like if she had a figurine, I would buy one for sure.
Looking at Svein respectfully... I just love her outfit, the sun motifs go so well with the rest of her accessories and props! I find her a bit more memorable than Riay in that regard, although she looks great as well!
Bio-wise, they both sound like such badass and fun characters it was hard to pick one, but I'll learn towards Svein more, once again-- I really appreciate how she's an aro character whose aromanticism gets addressed (and in such a fun way too... she's so right), and bonus points for being alloaro too because that's so rare! Although I feel sorry for not picking Riay because she's such a cool elderly character... love how she's teaching new generations and everything ;; <3 Such a heartwarming character without being too overwhelmingly sweet
Personally like Tobie more, or maybe it's because I really love and am biased to those soft boy outfits before that had kids in the 1940's just running around in the meadows and having fun sjhdje
I also love how significantly cold his pallette is and I most especially love how it contrasts to the character against him in this VS post ! You see warm colors everywhere and then there's just he, vibing with his fishing pole and justndjehehe adorableee
!!
Let's see which is hotter—
He screams daddy issues, he's the man that personally keeps me up at night just thinking of what I would do if he robbed or killed me as he is in the mafia (I eventually decided to just run, he's half snow leopard so I'm dead if he touches me-) — Viktor !!
Versus this conniving lil bastard that somehow romances ten women in one multiverse, and has met their mothers, and keeps getting more simps than my main oc just because he's 'manipulative' and can 'smash' , (still offended) Nico !!