I don't think I saw a thread for this with this type of idea yet, so let's launch it! Similar to my comment on the above OC thread, this one's all about artwork. This thread will be moderated on my main, ElithianFox, please PM me there for any inquiries!Â
Playing conditions
- This game is more about getting someone's commentary about your artwork, rather than using a site's comment functionality. If you still wish to get the comment somewhere (dA, FA, etc.), feel free to link to the specific site you'd like it on, but keep in mind not everyone may have an account on an off-site place! In that case, the comment will just be posted in this thread.
- If you'd like to get the comment on TH, make sure your image comments and notifications are on. This can be done here, by scrolling underneath your profile's text.
- Only post your own artwork unless you have the explicit permission from the artist to post their artwork for commentary.
- Any artwork is okay, except explicit NSFW, gore, joke art, and potentially triggering content like self harm, suicide, and hate crimes. Even if it doesn't show an OC, art showing fanart, scenery, CS, real people, etc. all are fine!
How to play
- Post a comment in the thread to claim the above person. Make sure to also post a piece of art you want commentary on OR a link to your gallery, and to state which nature of comments you are okay with getting. The piece can be any art, doesn't have to include any OCs!
- Look at the artwork posted. Don't just glance over it, take a good look at it and interpret it as you see fit.
- Write out a thoughtful comment about the artwork that's at least a couple of sentences long.
- Edit your claim with your comment. If you commented on the source the person gave, also link the comment to that place!
Rules
▶︎ The nature of comment you write can be anything, but it must be positive in some way. This can include constructive comments as long as they're not mean. Some examples of comments you can write:Â
• Compliments
• Constructive critiques <Only when stated this is okay>
• Things that stood out about the art
• What you enjoyed about the art
• Elements like the colours, composition, technical details, etc.
• How the characters are drawn
• Questions about the creation process
• Feedback on how to further improve their art <Only when stated this is okay>
• Etc.
▶︎ Quality over quantity! Still your comment has to be at least a couple of sentences long with no limit on maximum length. "Cool" and "Nice artwork" comments are empty and not so pleasant to receive, so please explain what you like about the piece, why you think it's a cool piece, what your thoughts are on the art, etc.
▶︎ If applicable, reading the piece's description can help better appreciate the piece!
▶︎ Intentionally mean, passive aggressive, or dismissive comments are instantly met with a strike, or in the worst case a ban from the game. Please be mindful; would you enjoy receiving the comment you wrote?
▶︎ Only post your own art, or others' art of your OCs if they have given permission to be posted in this thread.
▶︎ Only critique people's art in your comment when they explicitly state they accept it. If you accept criticism, please do state so when you claim, otherwise it won't be given!
▶︎ This thread is only for OOC comments on the art, no IC ones this time.
▶︎ Please make an effort to respond to the comment you receive. Even if it doesn't say what you expected, a simple "Thank you!" should be the minimum of a response. You don't have to have or continue a conversation, but can aim for one regardless!
▶︎ You can post twice per page, or once every 24 hours, whichever takes longer. However, if the thread is stuck for over three days, this rule is voided.
▶︎ If you are a frequent poster, please stray from always posting the same piece of art to be commented on! That way there's a much larger chance you will be claimed compared to always posting the same piece.
This thread operates under a three strikes system. Writing very low effort comments, passive aggressive comments, or comments that simply aren't nice to receive will get you a strike and a PM warning, and three gets you blacklisted.
Happy commenting!