♡ Redline/Critique The Artwork Above You! ♡

Posted 1 month, 26 days ago (Edited 1 month, 25 days ago) by Crazyclaw

I know there have been similar games, but I wanted to make this specific one!
Instead of showing your whole gallery or recent art, pick one piece in particular ^w^
While redlining & critiquing the art piece of the person above

I'll try to stay on top of moderation- if someone doesn't finish their claim do let me know and I'll handle it!

RULES:

1. Keep it NICE! always offer compliments alongside the criticism
2. Finish claim within 2 weeks, if you can't then feel free to message me and let me know
3. No sexual images or intense gore- artistic nudity and mild injuries are ok though!
4. Remember only one image can be done at a time; You can give options for the person below to pick from, but ultimately only one will be critiqued.
5. It doesn't have to be a fullbody redline, even just small parts or tips are ok
6. That's all! <3

Examples of a redline can be seen below (click on them for source)

_ratty__by_hikarihiddenleaf___redlining_tumblr_inline_pat8dqJSsv1qf3dsw_1280.png

I have some art below of mine, pick whichever one you prefer~


cottagecorecat_by_cat_frog_dgas3fg-pre.jclipshit_redlinemaybe_by_cat_frog_dh0p2w

ehh_unicorn_red_by_cat_frog_dh0p3n2-414w

Aarix

the shape of the wings will depend on what kinda bird u base them on but here's something

ZnTd8ei.png


--

options. go nuts on whatever u reckon.

.72126993_xUZR3HKdBxD2yH4.jpg?169852735478833746_txodU8wNOBjUjJL.png

77356764_ty7Ut4ZuLDbi7aC.png

swag thank you!

Cruxian

Aarix claim! 

a bitta critique 

IMG_2957.png?ex=66081a56&is=65f5a556&hm=


IMG_2955.png?ex=66081a56&is=65f5a556&hm=

Feel free to do any from here :]


79209263_KRxyOlCPR8oJqud.png?1710583452


78922244_u8OYKettX1JPxTP.png


78868164_pAJOvYsFNZ8wZhf.png

Scared_Gekko

Cruxian claim! 

this is what I noticed hope it helps! ^_^

I think the pose isn't clear enough and lacks a rhythm, if he's taking a step he should be leaning forward a bit more  for example.

x0rXjCb.png

here for you to dismantle ^▽^)

80456938_ajlmT6EijSED8iQ.jpg?171283155878095060_MejCvRwYi.png76149417_RENbJ6TRHHK2p9I.png




Crazyclaw

(NOT CLAIMING)

just a reminder; offer positive feedback alongside the critique ^u^
it's a kind way to help the artist understand something they're doing well

Crazyclaw

Scared_Gekko I decided to claim actually!haha-lol.gif 
Initially avoided it because my grasp on humans isn't the best but, eh why not?

I went ahead and critiqued the lute image, focusing on pose/dimension
First I focused on body, then a separate one for the lute (didn't want all my lines overlapping lol)
I changed the leg position to fit the idea of 'leaning back against invisible wall' thing- but I think your pose works well even just as a character floating in space :b


dh9dvjp-6e3b1501-177b-46c0-8431-c387888eredline_lute_by_cat_frog_dh9dvk1-414w-2x

and NOW, below I'll post some pics of mine that feel off.. plz help meilikeitplz.png?1

or tbh, if you want to skip feel free, I just want this thread to survive haha

EDIT: thank you so much, that is wicked helpful! <33


63547301_8PCnKWiSH2OJETL.png?1689452828dgas3fg-361e1459-2617-42b2-8fa7-3ba2f9a1 clipshit_redlinemaybe_by_cat_frog_dh0p2w


This user is not visible to guests.
This user is not visible to guests.
This user is not visible to guests.