Here are just a few of my non-smiling OCs:
Hengshui - Doesn't smile, mainly bc of his depression, and also because he literally can't bring himself to do so anymore.
Yunnan - Mainly because he's a cynic??? Idk tbh- mainly because of school and being in The Flames of the Sky (the Flametail army, hence his outfit).
Shangri-La - Doesn't smile due to stress and minor issues from being paparazzied by fans after he beat someone in a fight.
Beijing - Has bad memories of his past and hates literally everybody, hence why he's always scowling and not smiling.
Dali - Same reason as Yunnan except he doesn't go to school anymore, he probably dropped out or something and is still trying to forget it, hence his frown.