rypnami (pinging as well because it's been a while)

Expectation: "Quite the shy person, aren't you? Not a lot of friends, but you love each of them dearly. Probably prefer to stick to routine and is afraid of changes. And this hoodie of yours... You wear it because it makes you feel safe, right? You don't like to show a lot of skin, and comfort will always prevail over fashion."

Reality: "Seems like I was mostly right. Has overlooked stuff but wasn't wrong. You remind me of... someone. Definitely a good person. Take care of yourself, okay, Nico?"

Expectation: "Oh..? You seem to be the... artistic type. Smoking, too. Though.. I'm not too sure on your gender, I do think you might be more of a solo type, wanting to do things alone most of the time, you know? You're wearing typically French things- or at least what I assume to be is french." 

Reality:  "An angel eh..? I'm surprised, though my expectations weren't far from what first meets the eye. I am surprised that you're interested in politics though."

Expectations:"Why does this person have fluff? Are those ears on his head? Is this wolf or I think he's a wolf ready for a beach? Does he like the beach or sunglasses are just cool?"

Reality: "A chill dude like me? I wouldn't mind meeting up with more normal lived people for once. At least I won't have to feel bad about how little I matter at times. I hope we both can swim and chill".

Expectation: "You look cute! A little green creature that maybe likes to garden? Greenery much? Might be cute but maybe deadly, or am I being too cautious? Either way you are quite adorable!"

Lucasia sighed and looked at the creature again.

"Oh yeah, do you like tea or coffee?" she asked.

Reality: "Oh, so you don't like to garden, are you not going to tell me? Eh, I was kinda right with the greenery part, you are green!" Lucasia first said after Sulfur introduced himself.

"And oh, you literally can't defend yourself? Ah...I guess that means you aren't that deadly as I thought. But I am correct on how adorable you are!" Lucasia said as she pat the creature on his head.

"Oh yeah, I can teach you how to fight if you want?" the Twilight Heroine offered.

VictoryVManga (tagging because it’s been a couple days haha)

Expectation: “Her eyes!!! They are so... Colorful! She seems to be peaceful and happy, if a little naïve... But her wardrobe... Sort of plain. Wonder if she actually has powers, or if she’s just a normal average Joe. But if she does have powers, she certainly doesn’t look it. Her ears aren’t pointy! Though I do appreciate the accessory in her hair. One can never draw enough attention to good hairdos!

Reality: “Well she certainly does have powers, though none I have seen from my own people. And I certainly don’t condone her use of... What was it... ‘freeze burning’ people? I pray that nobody dares give her another cup of coffee. Our world may come to an end swiftly. I should probably warn my daughter...”

(Bumper)

HabelNotHable (following your example and tagging because it's been a few days!)

Expectation: "Huh. That hair, those wings...I'm already getting ideas. Not every day you see some kind of magic bird-woman, right? I'm not gonna waste that chance. The lighting from that glow might be tricky to capture, especially with all that jewelry reflecting it. But, hey, I like a challenge, and that's a neat fit. You seem a little nervous, though. Just chill for a bit, okay? Don't fly off before I'm done."

Reality: "You're royalty? Dang, okay. And a mom, huh? Well, maybe this should be a family portrait instead, especially since you like kids. And hey, what's it like seeing through a bird's eyes? Maybe you could describe it for me sometime. Sounds cool. You know, you're a sweet lady, Eirene. Oh, the painting? It's all yours once I'm done. I'll just grab a picture of it first for my insta."

Boop bump

ilex

Expectation: Pellis looked the woman over, "You're so.... vibrant. They muttered "You must be very energetic, or really sad. It is one or the other."

Reality: "Somewhere between you say? I see." the monstrocity looked at her paintings, "It seems almost... magic."

robot-star

Expectation: Upon first glance, there doesn't seem to be much of a reaction from her at all. A quiet acceptance with a nod. "They seem as though they may be an intimidating sort at first, but looking closer... They have very kind eyes."

Reality: "A guard, hmm? And serving with soldiers? Well, that explains things... But those eyes don't lie. A heart of gold, indeed. What an absolute darling."

Expectation- the lovely lady seems like a shy kind of person! Infact kinda melancholy if anything! Possibly has a hobby they stick to?? Gardener??

Reality- I was correct about most things! To my surprise! Mary is a gardener with a hobby,  one consisting of science! But it doesn't say she's shy... well it was really a pleasure getting to know mary!