✨ Who do you prefer between...?

Posted 6 years, 2 months ago (Edited 1 year, 1 month ago) by fuelli
This thread has rules regarding the effort you have to put in your replies. Please read them carefully before claiming and posting. Violation of these rules could lead to a warning or a ban from my forum games.

This game is simple to play! Post the link to two of your OCs (don't make people have to search through all of your characters lmao), and the user below has to tell which one they prefer and why! (With an OOC explanation) Then they post two of their OCs as well, and so on.

The two OCs to choose from can be anything! They may be related in some way in their story, they may be similar, they may be polar opposites, they may have the same number of faves, they may be chosen at random... Go wild and have fun comparing OCs ~


Rules and guidelines

About your claims

  • Read the above OCs' bios, and do comment about them, not just the designs. Bringing up the designs is fine, but it must not be the only thing you talk about. Preferences based on appearances only are better suited for the low-effort version of this game. 
  • Write an actual, thoughtful reason of why you prefer a character over another. A simple "I like their design better" or "I find them more interesting" and nothing else isn't really enough; try to be specific.
  • Be fair: if the person above you took the time to write a paragraph, don't give them one or two short sentences only in return.
  • Stay nice when you explain why you prefer one character over another. Don't make passive-aggressive, inappropriate remarks on other people characters, whether it's the duo or just the one you didn't choose. It's a 'who you prefer' choice, not a 'who you dislike the less' one.

About the characters you post

  • Please make sure the OCs you post have bios with enough substance for the next poster to have something to write about them.
  • If you got no response after a long time (let's say 1 or 2 days), it's recommended to edit the end of your post, suggesting a new duo to make the thread keep going.
  • For everyone's comfort, please refrain from posting NSFW or otherwise possibly disturbing characters. If you really do want to use such OCs, please offer a second pair to choose from, so the game doesn't get stuck.

If you find these rules too strict and want to play a low effort comparison game instead, you can try this variant!


Let's start for real now! Who do you prefer between Isabelle and Ismaël?

thedrowsydrow

AlleycatIrony I prefer Xenneth! Not only 'cause I kinda relate to him, being introverted and all, but his design and personality really appeal to me! His colors work nicely together, and I love how much you've written on him, he seems to be well-rounded and thought out.

(Hmm let's go with my polar opposite mains lmao) Who do you prefer between Neerfein and Nikko?

(Edit: Awww tysm ;u; He is my precious son who just wants everyone to be happy and loved <3)

clockrobber

Neerfein has stolen my heart. He seems very sweet and I also Love pink. He’s also got a very interesting backstory and I love his setting! I’m cheering for him...

~~~

Choose between space racer Janus and cute cat maid Nell 

pajuxi

I COULD NOT BE ANYMORE IN LOVE WITH JANUS his design and colors....his plot.....his everything is perfect and I love him very much omg 


Who do you prefer- Kurobe or Serell?

hedgemaze

clockrobber God, they're both great characters. "Cat maid cop" is an amazing concept, but I have to go for Janus. Underground space racing sounds really fun and compelling, and his visual design is great!

edit: I need to learn to claim lmao.

pajuxi They're both super charming characters, but I gotta go for cow guy, lmao. He's adorable and I love that he's a mascot and works at a petting zoo?? Perfect.



Drummer vs. drummer! Xero or Bane?

This user is not visible to guests.
Skulltopus

I just might have to go with Romeo on this one. I really like his design tbh he's rocking that pirate look which I'm also a sucker for. I can only imagine how beautiful his ship looks. Hah! Overall he seems like a very fun OC as is!!

--

I don't have many, gotta put up more, but how about... Pure mean vs Kind soul? Arioch or Milton?

dogstarlite

I LOVE ARIOCH but I'd stay far away from him, lmao. Gotta go with Milton!! We're somewhat alike. :>

---

Let's see... Wererabbit vs werewolf! Peach Honey or Olivia?

TheLadyAnatola

I'd say I prefer Peach Honey, mostly because I like the colors a little bit more, along with the concept of a tough person growing flowers and working in a flower shop being pretty charming in general. :3


Joy or Ragnarok?

This user is not visible to guests.
Opossun

It's so hard to choose only one of the brothers i feel kinda bad having to pick one. Buuuuuut i had to pick Blue. Firstly because I really like her design more, she is very unique! Then, she is also a very interesting character, being undead and also half blind. It's interesting to see how it would work on her story, if you intend to write more for her. I'd be sure interested!


Who do you prefer? The big weird Damien or the tiny weird Leslie ?

fuelli

I'd say Leslie because I'm more into pastel colours! I wanna steal all his clothes tfgvhbjnk,,

Also the thing about his special room... it's so adorable yet super sad, also I guess I relate??


Let's see two cute, polite boys... Who do you prefer, Tobie or Gabriel?

Dohmalore

Tobie....is too small......too innocent.....must be protected.  I know if I saw him on a tv show or something i'd be just panicking on his behalf watching him just, obliviously, accidentally avoid extreme danger,,,,,,,,Thank u Raphael for keeping him safe

---

Who do you prefer between Innit & Zenith?

hedgemaze

They're both interesting characters, but I have to go with Zenith. I really like that she saves people and works hard, but doesn't actually care about people at all. Being in it just for the duty is a really interesting motivation, and I like that she's the sort of person who needs someone to tell her what to do. That's a really grounded, human trait for a fantasy character. I also really like her look: it's distinctive and elegant, but not cluttered.


Noisy friend or brooding friend? Izzy or Haggis?

This post has been removed.
windfall

OOF dallas immediately.. i love his heterochromia, his colors are Heart eyes, i just. oof. and he's a tall boy. i love him so much? and hair. heart eyes. i just love him so much.

lucidia or jax