Say something nice about the above person's lit!

Posted 5 years, 8 months ago (Edited 5 months, 7 days ago) by hedgemaze

I've wavered about making this thread for a while because I'm not sure if it's too close to other games, but there can never be too many opportunities to say nice things about other people's work, I think! :')

In this game, you'll post a link to a literature you've written here on Toyhouse that you're proud of, and the person below will tell you what they like about it! In turn, you'll tell the person who posted above you what you like about theirs.

Rules:

  • I don't want to impose a specific word limit, but try to pick literatures that aren't too overwhelmingly long to read: if you have a whole novel here on Toyhouse, just link a chapter! If the person below loves it, they can read the rest in their own time, but they're not obligated to for this game.
  • Please write at least a few sentences for the person above you, and write something of substance! You don't have to write a dissertation on the piece, but write the kind of response that you'd love to receive! What about the piece did you like, or what did the writer do particularly well in the piece?
  • Remember that this is a compliment thread (there is a separate thread for writing critique)! Please avoid criticism unless the person above you said they wanted it!
  • You can post content-warned or mature-rated literatures, but you must mark that they are, and PLEASE LINK an all-ages lit as an alternate option in your post, to prevent the thread from becoming stuck if minors want to participate, or if people might just be uncomfortable with the subject matter. 
  • It's also OK to post alternate options for any reason! If you'd really prefer your first lit to be reviewed, it's fine to say that and even post a time limit if you want; For example: "I'd really love feedback on Lit A, but if a day passes, Lit B is fine as well!"
  • All writing posted in this thread should be hosted on Toyhouse, via the literature feature! No off-site links, please.
  • Claim first so you have time to read the person's lit and craft your response!
  • Please ping the person above you so you make sure that they see your comment! If you're not sure how to do this, you simply type @THEIRUSERNAME, and they will be notified! This will not work if you edit the ping into your comment later (like if you wanted to claim and then edit your comment in); you must put it in when you first submit the comment.
  • You are NOT ALLOWED to skip anyone in this thread. If you cannot see the post above you because the poster or you have blocked each other, wait for another person to comment before replying to the thread. Feel free to bump the thread to encourage others to participate!
  • Let at least two people go before posting again. If you post in this thread often, try to vary the lit you post! If the thread gets stuck for a week or more, it's fine to post again even if only one person has gone since your last post.
  • You can bump the thread as often as you like; I don't mind.
  • BE NICE!  
Other literature/writing games I highly recommend:
The first person to post can just link one of their lits and receive a free response. Have fun!

All my forum games and threads

muichiro

and here we are! so, i read your smiley thing like a few hours after you released it. my comment was half assed on it, i apologize for that ieghsdg, i think i was hungover that day so my communicating skills were bare minimum. that aside, happy together is really great. the way you started it was wonderful. i remember reading it at first and being attached into it. the instant start of drama is good, i love suspense and drama and you catered to both of those things very well. the internal writing for this character is also really good. you feel her dread. you feel as if you're understanding her perspective and how upsetting it is. some writers (professional ones too at that), don't put that life into the situations, and even though she's a minor character; she's still human. and that's important, at least to me.

my next point is your dialogue. this is a huge struggle for many people, myself included. you do it really really well, seamlessly well. when reading your interactions, i forget that you're the one pulling the puppet strings, that you're the one doing it all. it's done so nicely that i think there's two people in each interactions, three whenever there's a third party and that's excellent! that's what you want to do with writing! make your characters and their interactions so believable that it's more than just one person essentially talking to themselves through writing and more like there's several people there. 

i also liked that you described lionel not at the start, but in the middle. it flowed really well and was an interesting way to do it. so many times, i personally get caught up and stressed at describing everything at once, you know? like who is this character. let me describe them right away. but that doesn't matter and placing it later on is great. it's a good way to introduce them better than giving the reader too much information at one time. i liked that a lot, and was like oh! this is who he is and this is why it matters. 

lastly, the area with smiley introduced. it was great, it was amazing. you took that character from before and made her more important than the victim she was. suddenly she was someone and as the reader, you just sat there like oh no...because dramatic irony. you knew what was going on, you realized that oh that's the..oh no it's not a good thing don't text her back, but the characters didn't. cyclical and well threaded, YOU made that happen and gave it such a good sensation that it was delightful. it was exciting to read and i wanted to know what came next. would they die? would they realize something was off? would they have a good evening and the killer (smiley) would just fuck around and then put the phone somewhere else? that's amazing stuff to have in writing. 

i struggle with reading writing a lot, i get unfocused and can't keep up well with the story..but your way of doing it kept my attention and allowed me to enjoy a really fantastic piece. so thank you for that and thank you for taking the time out to write it. you did a great job!!! >W< be proud of yourself and your work! smiley is a spooky boy and he's such a wonderful character. 

--

@ NP, i have like 2 things in my library. cannibal corpse is more of actual writing if you want to check that out. 

This user is not visible to guests.
This user is not visible to guests.
damascus

ALRIGHT: Patience and Prudence started out so bright and calm, and ends so dark. But there are clues within the piece that point you along to the end; the priest with his halo of flowers evokes an image of a crown of thorns to me. The preacher's empty plate, saving his appetite for later. At that point, having not yet read the character's profile, I was expecting the preacher to get up and just devour everyone in the congregation. The imagery of the preacher walking down the halls to the bound woman is vivid; I'm picturing this disturbingly disfigured woman, and this preacher in all white entering the room with a gentle smile on his face. And then we return to the idea of "sweetness" --the red "couldn't have sounded any more sweet as it did, today," which, to me, takes me back outside to where these people are frolicking and enjoying their fruits and sweet breads, where everything is clean white pristine, and no one hears, or chooses to hear, what's going on inside the church. I LIKE IT. That vicious dichotomy of red on white is just so... (chefs kiss) And then I DID read the character's profile, saw that this preacher leads a cult and PERSUADES his followers to give him blood... And I wonder, did this woman choose this? Was she chosen for it? How many of them outside know exactly what's going on inside the church, how many of them are thinking "lucky her" or "well at least it's not me!" Suddenly this bright glowing scene is so sullied, so dark. I love it even more.

Your imagery and storytelling are superb, basically! I'll check out your other works a little later when I have more reading time!


Next person: You can peruse my whole lit section but if you're looking specifically for something all-ages friendly, might I recommend reading a little of the first chapter of Punch Cat! ? It's a little long, so don't feel pressured to read it all, and of course feel free to pick another piece!

SapphireBatWings

damedanbo pinging because it has been so long

I think that the thing that stoodut to me the most was your descriptive language (especially at the very beginning). I loved how you described the city lights and the florescent neon. I think that it was a cool note that the power plant might be causing a lack of snow fall. You just kind of painted a picture of the world in my head.

I also think that you did a splendid job balancing the amount of dialogue vs action which is super important in an action story imo. Like neither the action nor the dialogue overpowered the other.

Another thing that I liked was your summary actually lol. I’m horrid at summaries. I think that the concept of cars becoming more human and being treated as second class citizens as a result is a compelling concept. So your creativity is something I enjoy with your writing.

Also Halley! I liked him as a character he’s spunky and fun and delightfully mischievous. “‘Boo! Booooo!’ Halley yelled, hands cupped around his mouth. ‘Get better one liners!’” Gave me a little lol. Honestly he radiates pure cat energy lmao.


I only have two pieces at the moment and both are short so feel free to pick either.

 

hedgemaze

SapphireBatWings (Sorry about the delay, got called away to deal with some things)

I picked "Alive in the Limelight." I saw a band story and I was there. I really appreciate your descriptive language in this; I've been to hundreds of concerts and I miss it, haha. This story really had the feel of being at a show, smoky and sweaty and alive, the band and crowd feeding off each other's energy, creating something special between them. You express the emotions of it very well, the band relishing in the performance and in teasing the increasingly rabid crowd, the crowd's enthusiasm growing to a frenzy, and Zakka's relief and exhilaration afterward, that the show went well and that their return was so welcomed. You do a good job at showing the magic of live music even before you get to the surprise of literal magic, which was a delight to read and I'm sure for the crowd to experience, too.

You describe the band members' instruments so intricately, and how their voices mesh together, that we know this is a band who's been together a long time and knows their identities well. Between that and their backstage camaraderie, the readers can feel why this show and its reaction would be just what they needed.

This was a fun read. Nice job!


Panthers is my most recent lit, but warning for some vulgar language and one homophobic slur (which neither I nor my characters condone). Feel free to pick any of my lits. I have many, and they're all short and require no prior context.

Edit: Thank you so much!!

lordsatin

hedgemaze

i decided to read panthers and that brought back some memories! i went to a catholic high school for my freshman year and it just so happened to coincide with my realization that i'm very gay. thankfully nothing this bad happened (they mostly pretended that lgbt people didn't exist) i got transferred out second year but still you really captured that oh so crappy feeling of hiding yourself.

two lines that i adore,
"a threat, calculated and deadly, cherry-balmed lips spitting the word with savored venom" is just incredible. i love how you described this. you can pretty much hear the exact tone of voice it would have been said in. i also really like the contrast of deadly and cherry-balmed being right next to each other. it really portrays the way the people you're describing hid behind personas. honestly your descriptions in general are just amazing, from the panthers to the way the characters moved and emoted. just awesome!
also, “I will punch a nun for you,” is just a great line (i actually chuckled irl when i read it) and the way that amber didn't react to the joke at first but then quipped back at the end really made me feel happy that she felt at least a little bit better. also "Heaven? I wouldn’t go if they’d have me." is a lovely cherry on top as a finishing line.

in general i really like this. i'm a sucker for comfort and it really made me happy to read the way that jill supports her friend. also, i really like how the story was paced out. it's very dialogue heavy but it never feels like talking heads. you did an amazing job balancing the dialogue and descriptions.

just a really good read! nice job!

------

my oneshots!

KilljoyLights

lordsatin
I read through the very first one on the list. It's definitely a good start to something really good. I would suggest a little more detail be added to the story. I'm simply talking about my own style of writing, but I try to get more into my character's head. Really capture the moment as if it was your character. I apologize if that doesn't make much sense as I'm not very good at critiquing things... The one shot in all felt short and a little rushed and could have taken a little more time in setting the scene. However it wasn't a boring read for its shortness. I enjoyed the set up a lot, though it left me with a lot of questions that I feel could have been explained in your narration. For example, what did Norian do to have hunters on her? How did the hunters find her out? Why is she self destructive? I'd love to learn more about this character! And as I said, you have the start of something really interesting and lore filled~  


This is only half done, but I'd love some thoughts on it anyways.
Hats
(Edit: You don't have to read all five parts if you don't want to.
I also have other works if Hats isn't your cup of tea.)

Kolo

KilljoyLights

I ended up working through a few chapters of Hats, and what stood out to me most was the juxtaposition in the work - you have this very cutesy title image, with simple shapes and a cute expression, and the story starts off very upbeat and cheery, so I was strapped in for something along the lines of comedic demon-y slapstick. Y'know, demons punting people and stealing their hats or something, where what they're doing is objectively awful but the narrative can frame it as hilarious. It then turned pretty hard into deep detail about these corpses/the necrophiliac character, which REALLY threw me at first. You have these bits of narrative where the main character's thinking through something harmless, like the buildup to the mirror scene, pressed up against the lurid description of his clothing and rot. 

I ended up really feeling for Belial, especially in the second chapter, as his plain need for attention/affirmation was really pitiful, especially when against someone like Jayden, who really barely seemed to genuinely care for him. Like, they're going on this quest for hats and Jayden cares about Belial clearly in terms of a possession or object, but fails to meaningfully connect with his actual wants and sense of self in any way except to exploit it, knowing Belial is loyal. I got the sense that what would really make Belial happy is Jayden accepting him fully and tempering some of his admiration towards the demon, but that he's too self-centered and self-focused to willingly do that. :( I would hug Belial but he has a gaping hole in his side so I think I'll just nod from a distance.

In the end I think the choices are interesting - not bad, but not my exact cup of tea either. Still, the amount of detail and prose dedicated to describing how much these characters are bad people/indulge in bad things/their messed-up dynamic is impressive, and a few of the lines unsettled me quite a bit! Out of curiosity, do you normally write gore/horror-ish stuff, or was this a first foray into it?


hm this post was really long NP please don't feel obligated to blabber like me haaaa
Anyways I offer any chapter of Tonight at our Beach, they're all somewhat standalone (or should be, anyways).
The first chapter has some flirting that borders on nudity jokes but nothing really explicit, but if you don't really like flirting I'd pick one of the other ones. The last one is probably most inexplicable to new readers, though. (If you read all the chapters you are a champion?? But please don't feel obligated har)

EDIT: THANK YOU.... i'm really really glad you liked it!! i'm always super happy to hear it invoked some feelings in people, especially for a story like this where the stakes are relatively low :'D thank you so much for the compliment on the dialogue, too!! i love writing characters blabbering (it's because i constantly go off on tangents).....

zinnia

-revs this thread alive again like the motor on a lawnmower-

Kolo

sorry if you got fave notif bombed the star wasnt fully responding for me so i kinda. mashed it. whoops

'For once there's no warnings or anything. Wholesome!' very good start and also relatable. beach episode time! i went ahead and read chapter 1

already i'm loving kolo and dij's dynamic..... it's very sweet ;___; especially as it goes on, it's the type of dynamic that kinda hits home but is also just... super sweet and wonderful to read? i LOVE how you do dialogue, it all sounds super realistic like, yea, these two are really having moments together.

the dance scene was really sweet as well!! i could clearly visualize how it was going and it's just?? i;m saying this a lot because it's TRUE but this entire thing is so sweet and warm feeling!! speaking of which, i adore how you described the feeling of warmth throughout in different ways..... makin me feel Emotions

tldr: youre very good with dialogue and emotions!!! they feel super real and was very pleasant to read :} i'll probably be coming back to this when i can!!

--

my lits tab is kind of a mess so here's my current world's library! feel free to choose anything from core works or oneshots - but do note core works are multichapter so best to choose a oneshot :0

OPIATHE

zinnia

https://toyhou.se/~literature/41271.lost-at-sea

This is a very good literature, the details are well presented, i like the interactions with both charcters. It really does make you feel you are with them both and it adds a feeling of reality 

It seems that in this literature, it seems that both characters are just getting to know each other, all drunk, and i like the idea of it!


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

https://toyhou.se/~literature/40706.void-the-guide

This is my literature sooo here you go!




Dakkokki

SaintKerosene

Sadly, I cannot seem to view anything on the last chapter, as it comes up with large circles with crosses through them, so I can't say much on that page. However, I do enjoy reading about alternate universes and what life on other planets may be like, so this was a very interesting read. But seeing as there's nothing on the creatures that inhabit it yet, I'll just have to wait for that one. However, from what you've written about the environment, I see it's a bit similar to how Earth is when it comes to locations, which is a nice thing to have, but the color scheme of the place really makes it seem alien in nature and I really enjoy the thought of almost a vaporwave-like world! I can't wait to see how you expand upon your universe you have going on! :D



I'm going to give two options depending on how much you want to read, the first here is 3.2k words, and the second is only a little over 500 words.



Aaaaa <3 thank you so much! ;w; I really hoped to solidify their personalities when writing, mostly so I can RP better and not have them deviate too out of character. Tbh, I never knew just how hard it was to write an extremely strong accent until I created and began writing out how Tsubakura speaks XD

TyrianCallows

Dakkokki

I ended up reading through both pieces and I have to say your writing style is just the right amount of world/mood building, character exposition, and action! In your first piece, you really grasped the tone you were going for and introduced me well to your character that I haven't read about before. I liked being able to understand through voice and action the motives and thoughts of your characters, it's one of the big things I've personally learned to do and learned to respect from watching twitch RPers explore their own characters by themselves while streaming, it makes you grow attached and get into their character more and you did it super well - Don't mind me hacking into the mainframe and invoking the scenes of Tsubakura on a more personal level, lol. 


I have two pieces for NP to read through, Arrival (1k words) and Decay's Corruption (500 words - But has some Pre-reading here). Feel free to choose!

This post has been removed.
This user is not visible to guests.