Characters more well-liked than you expected?

Posted 5 years, 11 months ago (Edited 5 years, 6 months ago) by hedgemaze

@Judas-la-carotte's thread about underrated characters made me think about the opposite! I'm not going to use the word "overrated" because I certainly don't mean that any OCs deserve less love, but do you have any characters whom you're surprised get more attention than you expected they would, among your characters?

Maybe people pick them more often in forum games or art trades than other characters, they have more faves than you expected, or they're just the ones your friends have gravitated towards for whatever reason-- but maybe they aren't among your own favorites, or they're just not the OCs you expected would be popular.

And has that character's popularity inspired you to use or develop them more, or give them a bigger role in whatever story or project they may be in?

There are no particular rules for this thread; just be nice and don't try to make people feel bad about their taste or anything like that.


All my forum games and threads

Peter Jensen truelexblue

this boy right here!! when i asked a bunch of my friends which oc of mine was their favorite, they all chose peter. he started off as a one-dimensional, insufferable jerk since i was bad at developing ocs at the time. but now, he's still a jerk, but his antics are a bit more palatable. that's mostly because i gave him a better side to himself (also i made him p cute skdsdkjk). he's a guy that loves to mess around with people, but he's also a good guy under all that. i even ship him w/ one of my friend's ocs!!

i just lov this idiot

Squish GothGremlin

this little guy was just a little mini sona for me to doodle, but people typically really like him, he gets lots of attention during art fight and he’s the main character I get random fanart for

Frequency hedgemaze

Frequency is another one that surprises me. It's not a character with a setting or anything; it's just a design I created for a funny robot art battle with a friend that was kind of jokingly based on my aesthetic and interests, so I don't think of the design as something well-polished or "good," but people often pick it as their favorite of my characters or the most iconic, and I think that's interesting?

I do like it and I want to draw it again sometime, but it's one of my very few characters who don't have a story.

Mayu Kenmai

Mayu has gotten a lot more favorites than i thought he would, especially since he's a blank vent character, but i guess maybe people are interested in the idea of him?

 Shiro flowey

shiro was originally kind of a joke oc i made to use as kind of a plot device for something i was wanting to write, who's name and design were kind of afterthoughts compared to my other characters (shiro's name was originally taken off of behindthename with very little forethought whereas a lot of my ocs had names with relevant meanings, and he only has green in his color scheme because none of my other ocs did). i ended up using him in a roleplay where he quickly became very well-liked and he's since then ended up growing on me and becoming my favorite oc, the 1 character i've kept for the longest amount of time, *and* my most developed character by far. i have a hard time developing my other characters nowadays bc i'm always preoccupied with shiro knadsgkndlg

Noel ♕ 🧶 SeaSlugs

This lil guy? I made 'im a long time ago. He was original a girl named Cath. Never was able to get rid of him (every couple of years I would completely revamp myself and either toss or majority edit my characters), so, I revamped his design a little. Nothing major, just new outfit (kept the old one anyway) and actually made a set fur pattern. Same role and personality. A little bit ago he got suddenly bombarded with faves and I'm still not really sure why! I feel like someone had promo'd him because I would get waves of faves and I know he wasn't on the random section TH has? x-x). The sudden attention freaked me out a lil LMAO

Quincy Kenmai

honestly quinnie here.... he's a bit of a clingy asshole that likes knives and memes
i guess thats enough to win most people over but it just happened so quickly fhkds... 40 favorites in a day... ive never had it happen before so im just surprised

Harahel fuelli

Don't get me wrong, I love him a lot too, but whoa, I'm surprised how much people seem to like Harahel... Seriously, in these past 24 hours I've posted like... 4 times in those "fave OC/steal an OC from the person above" and Hara was picked... 4 times. Lmao why, I have over 80 OCs uploaded on TH

I won't lie, he was pretty unnoticed at first and I had to post him in a favourite feature thread to kick-start him a bit, but now he doesn't even need that to get faves haha. Someone even said that he was one of my "most iconic OCs" and I was like??????????? I've had him for less than a month

I'm happy to see that he gets a bit of recognition, and it motivates me to flesh out his concept even more! The only things that bugs me a bit are when people only praise his design and ignore his bio, since he was designed by someone else... I appreciate the thought but guys please at least comment on something I actually worked on :') I also fear that he may overshadow some of my other characters who are more important than him in my universe, since he is only a non-canon character to me, but hey, maybe that's just because he is new. Time will tell.

CANNIBALent

Ollie is super popular among my friends and for RP's, and at a certain level I understand it. He's kind of the bad boy, the villain. But like, they LOVE him. They want him to be HAPPY. This OC is a CANNIBAL, I created him to be the absolute opposite of the moral compass as a few of my other characters. He's supposed to be liked and hated. But no, he's LOVED. Blows my mind every time.

Gravel Clay ShadmeTheAngel

For whatever reason, when I was writing The Fire Within (the story this guy's from), Gravel was the favorite character amongst all my friends. I was so baffled to hear that. XD I imagined that he was going to be semi-forgettable among the main cast, but my friends adored him. Made it really hard to pull off a plot twist I had planned, but y'know. It happens, lol!

Marcel clumsypups

even though he seems like a plain design to most, he's also received a lot of favorites and people seem to favorite him a lot!! it makes me happy bc he was an expensive gift from someone and i cherish him a lot <3

Dr Joeseph Willheim thegrumpydruid

I was not expecting my murderous vampire to get so much love.... Honestly he has a few dedicated fans and it blows me away... People like him??? I guess people have a thing for bad boys... Well, he's actuallya nice, good guy.. He just has murderous tendancies that he uses to feed his brood of vampires